Factory Visit: Gitman Bros.

Tucked into the foothills of the Appalachians, in Ashland, a town borne of the once-thriving Pennsylvania coal mines, sits a two story house. That house is home to one of the last great American shirt makers, Gitman Bros.

“This was Shelly Gitman’s home away from home,” Gitman President John Minahan explained when I visited last May. “He’d use this place to get away from the wife whenever he needed to.”
The basement of Shelly Gitman’s former home. The factory is the size of four football fields.

He’s not kidding. And neither am I. The state-of-the-art Gitman Bros. factory is built into the basement of Sheldon Gitman’s former home. The ladies who work in the first and second floor offices — really just converted bedrooms — use the pea green tiled bathroom as one of their break rooms. “How often do you find a microwave on the master bedroom sink?” One of the women quipped. They seem to love the quirky aspects of their surroundings. “See those file cabinets? They’re in an old walk-in cedar closet!” One exclaimed.

Max Gitman in a light suit (R) with the employees of the Ashland Shirt & Pajama Co., 1940

In the late 1930s, Max Gitman, a shirt contractor in Brooklyn, struggling to keep his factory going amidst pressures from rackets and unions, joined forces with other shirt makers — the predecessors of Eagle, Gant, Kenneth Gordon, and Sero, to name a few — and moved one-hundred-fifty miles away, to booming Pennsylvania where they’d ply their trade. While the men worked the coal mines, Max and his cohorts would train the women to become skilled shirt makers. With the culture of shirt making fully ingrained, for many years, Ashland, this lump, this tiny chunk of the coal region became known as a hotbed of better shirt making.

While in the last thirty years, most of the factories have closed shop and shipped their production overseas, Gitman stands tall. I was shocked to learn that many of the employees of Gitman are third and fourth generation shirt makers, and sometimes all three are still employed with mother handing off to daughter handing off to daughter. In this place, they talk of “good needles;” which is to say, a trained sewer is raised in the culture. Anyone can learn to sew, but, as I learned on my visit to the Quoddy Moccasin factory, where they struggle to find and train new handsewers, to have been born and raised into this has become a treasure in this country. In the morning meeting, I loved watching while three different solutions were offered for how to best turn a collar, hands flying this way and that over a pile of broadcloth.

Max Gitman with his sons Alfred and Sheldon

Mr. Gitman ran the company, along with his twin sons Alfred and Sheldon until his death in the early 60s. By 1978, Al and Shelly had become pros of production, making private label shirts for all comers, but they’d yet to make a name for themselves. At the prodding of a few of their hip and happening salesmen, they re-branded a particularly popular sport shirt, their button downs. They called the shirts “Gitman Bros.” Loaded with trademark finishes such as a double track stitched collar, chalk buttons, a third collar button on the back, a locker loop, a box pleat, the option of a pop-over (at the time an innovation), and by making them up in some of the wildest plaids this side of the Atlantic, they set the sport shirt world ablaze. “For a while, Gitman was The Cool Shirt,” Mr. Minahan assured me. “Al and Shelly chose the chalk buttons because they were cheap. Pretty soon, everybody was making shirts with chalk buttons: Gant, Polo, you name it.”

Gitman Vintage’s Chris Olberding discusses tag placement for the line’s latest innovation. For Spring 2011, they will offer a selection of Japanese organic fabrics.

Fast-forward thirty years. One day while at the factory, Gitman’s youngest associate, Chris Olberding stumbled upon a dusty pile of old line books, and his mind started racing. “It was perfect. It was exactly what I saw happening in the marketplace,” he explained.

Starting with the vintage t-shirt hunters and sneaker freakers, the youth culture began turning its eyes to things of the past, quality products made with care in a manner considered old-fashioned, nearly dead. The same kid who’d spent $1000 on a pair of original Nike Waffles was investing in a pair of Danner Boots, also made in Oregon, and not far from where those Waffles originated. Selvage denim became coveted. The heavier, the better. Work boots, canvas bags, and naturally, the progression lead to shirts. Where in other aspects of the culture — the food industry in particular — supporting small, local businesses began to take hold, folks wanted to buy things made closer to home, because it required less fossil fuels to ship that thing to its final destination.

For Spring of 2011, part of what Mr. Olberding is calling his “Jungle Collection,” he’s offering a Camouflage and Blaze Orange shirt, a bolder choice along with several animal prints.

The yoke of a Vintage madras, cut and ready.

Plus, the fabrics are unlike anything out there. “There are patterns, stripes, plaids in these books that no one has seen in thirty years,” notes Mr. Olberding. But Gitman Bros. was unknown to the young customer (The only reason I knew Gitman was because a former employer assigned me to track down Thom Browne’s shirt maker). Over the course of the last thirty years, the brand grew old with its hip and happening customer of the 70s. It got fatter, too. Mr. Olberding trimmed the fat, four inches in total. He worked with the factory’s artisans to perfect the fit, and then he went about reproducing some of his favorite fabrics from the archives. And like that, they took off. More athletic than a Band of Outsiders, less relaxed than a Steven Alan, in its fourth season, the Gitman Vintage shirt is now regarded as one of the best-fitting shirts around. The basic button down oxford sells just as well as a stripe or a plaid from the 1980s.

A blouse for Gitman Sisters and a shirt for Gitman Boys

“Sometimes, I stand at the end of the line with tears in my eyes,” Mr. Minahan whispered. Holding the finished product, his pride and joy, “Look at it. This is a beautiful shirt. Nobody makes a sized dress shirt better than us. Nobody.”

Warehouse Manager, Diane Moser removes the Gitman label and applies a heat-sealed private label to a wing collar tuxedo shirt.

Shirts are packed two-to-a-box and labeled with a bar code and the store name. This box of Vintage shirts is going to A.GI.EMME, a store in Como, Italy.

A co-labeled shirt, like the ones seen here were once the standard among finer men’s boutiques in the United States.

Producing private label shirts, like this Regent Street Shirt for Cable Car Clothiers, was the majority of the business for Max Gitman.

Hundreds of file cabinets line the walls of the warehouse, stuffed with tags from retailers new and old who have made shirts at the Gitman Bros. factory.

“Fine Attire & Great Conversations.” This tag for Baton Rouge store, Louisiana Lodge is a personal favorite. Note the shotgun, fishing pole, antlers motif.

There are thousands of these tags on file.

This was the original label for Gitman Bros.

Monogramming is also big business for the factory.

They sell to golf pro shops all over the world.

Gitman Vintage yoke bundles await their fate.

Chest pockets await placement.

Patsy “Pockets” Schaeffer attaches chest pockets to the left front of shirts.

Ms. Schaeffer shows off her handiwork.

Of everyone I met, Patsy seemed to love her job the most. With a wide smile and a big laugh, she takes real pride in her work and has a great time in the process.

Where sleeve meets cuff, there is formed a small house-shaped opening, called the doghouse. You can see that with a quick origami move, it’s formed entirely by hand.

Once a shirt is finished, it goes here to Cathy Yagodzinskie. She examines each shirt for loose threads, any flaws, and makes sure they’re ready to ship.

Before heading to packaging, the shirts are pressed and folded. Of all the machine presses, the sleeve machine was my favorite. Before, they look tired and lumpy.

After, stiff as a plane’s wing.

Break Time.

For more of my visit to Gitman Bros. see Flickr. Special thanks to all the folks at Gitman for a terrific visit.


  1. davidH
    June 30, 2010

    Awesome! Thanks for posting this.

  2. Jeremiah
    June 30, 2010

    Possibly the best documented and most interesting post on a shirtmaker I have ever read.

    Well done sir.

  3. Brad
    June 30, 2010

    Wonderful post. I’m wearing my G Bros chambray as I type this, and appreciating it all the more having had a glimpse into the factory from which it came. I can’t wait to see those Japanese organics.

  4. […] you are a man who owns shirts… stop waisting your time reading this and make the jump over to All Plaidout right […]

  5. James of Secret Forts
    June 30, 2010

    epic, sir.

  6. unitedstyle
    June 30, 2010

    Damn, this was the king of factory tour posts. Well done.

  7. Rob Sawyer
    June 30, 2010

    This was great. Thanks for posting and taking the time to document the tour.

  8. john minahan
    June 30, 2010

    Three generations of skilled American factory craftspeople….proud and private….OUTED.Thanks, Max, this was a story that needed to be shown well and you did that.I never walk thru the finishing area without thinking how profoundly beautiful the shirts made by the Ashland workers are time by time.We are proud to be thriving,but too much of this irreplacible American beauty has already died.
    I hope someone somewhere pays the same mind to this extinction of a culture, as they do to that of a species.SAVE AMERICAN FACTORIES,THEY CANNOT BE REPLACED.

  9. Jesper
    July 1, 2010

    Very well put together. My first visit here, more to come.

  10. Jim B
    July 1, 2010

    A great story about an unusual place. It’s amazing to see how much hand work goes into a Gitman shirt.

  11. Marco
    July 1, 2010

    Thoroughly enjoyable tour behind Gitman Bros. Thanks for allowing us to tag along.

  12. Turling
    July 1, 2010

    Excellent and thorough post. Our Company purchases another company a few year’s ago and that company’s corporate offices were out of a converted one story home. They kept the office supplies on shelves in the shower. It was awesome.

  13. JRS
    July 1, 2010

    Simply awesome. I like seeing people who take pride in their work. Always been a fan of Gitman, this only helps confirm.

  14. Chris Andrew
    July 1, 2010

    This is phenomenal. Great read & I just picked up two Gitman shirts. Planning on them lasting me a life time!

  15. P
    July 2, 2010

    Put me down for the camo shirt.

  16. […] e dei brand, più pettinati del mondo. Se vuoi vedere la fabbrica dove si produce Gitman Vintage, All Plaid Out ha un bel servizio fotografico. Gitman Vintage è una collezione heritage, tributo al passato del […]

  17. Miguel Ramalhão
    October 24, 2010

    Loved the post !!! I’m a fan of Gitman Shirts!

  18. […] the ever-tasteful fellows at Canada’s Inventory Magazine (but still produced in Gitman’s fabled Ashland, PA facility), the line is crafted from an array of Japanese organic cotton fabrics (two ginghams, two stripes), […]

  19. […] our spring shipment is still a couple of weeks out, we thought our customers might like to see this tour of the Gitman Bros. factory in Ashland, Penn. from All […]

  20. David Aaron Gitman
    November 6, 2011

    Thank you for the article and photos. My sons (Marcus and Brian) are Max’s great grandsons. I remember Shelly, Doris, Mitch, Claudia, and Gabe living in the apartment above the factory. Three generation of Gitmans enjoyed your collection of photos and the accompanying story, while we were all visiting at my home in upstate New York, this past weekend. Sincerely, David Gitma

  21. Martin
    April 7, 2012

    This was a fascinating entry. Thanks so much! I bought some Gitman Bros. shirts at Alexander-Beegle in Virginia when I was in college; at the time I didn’t know anything about the shirtmaker other than the quality was outstanding. Still some of my favorite shirts. I also have great clothing from Mallards in Chicago from my grad school days. Mallards was founded by my old friend Joe Cecil, who eventually went to work for IAG/Gitman. It’s so neat how this all seems to come full-circle.

  22. David Friedberg
    June 17, 2012

    Had the pleasure of meeting Shelly Gitman yesterday. A very interesting and gracious gentleman. He was wearing one of his short sleeve sport shirts, and gave me quick tutorial about a quality shirt.

  23. […] renamed the company Gitman Brothers in 1978. For more history, see MORTAR (the first link) or allplaidout, which also includes a factory tour. Many of the shirts made by Gitman Brothers Vintage are made by […]

  24. […] Special thanks to our friend, Max Wastler of All Plaidout for being an excellent source of information on Gitman. See his indepth factory visit to Ashland, PA here. […]

  25. […] For more of my experience at the factory, be sure to read this post. […]

  26. John Johnston
    March 27, 2014

    I have worked in economic development in PA for 15 years… and I have NEVER seen so inspiring a story about what can be done in clothing manufacturing right here in the USA. Wow, and kudos to the Gitman family and the dedicated workers! I’ve a few Gitman shirts, but I never realized they were totally made right here in PA.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *