Camp Wandawega’s Seedy Past - Elkhorn, WI

Camp Wandawega’s Seedy Past - Elkhorn, WI

Two hours north and west of my hometown of Chicago exists a dreamlike place complete with olive green tents, fishing by the bonfire, a two-story tree house, and a hotel building crammed with countless relics from days gone by. It’s called Camp Wandawega. Overseen by husband and wife owners Tereasa Surratt and David Hernandez, in the past five years, Wandawega has become something of a home-away-from-home for me.

2

Hernandez and Surratt purchased the site a little over a decade ago. Growing up in Chicago, it had been Hernandez’s summer camp as a kid. Putting in hours upon hours of hard labor, the couple have in recent years re-opened the place. When Surratt learned I’d be working for Basil Hayden’s, her initial thought was, “oh, you should tell the story of the speakeasy!” This is my attempt to do so.

According to their website, in 1925, Chicagoans allegedly seeking to capitalize on the opportunities presented them by Prohibition built The Wandawega Hotel on a weeded body of water called Lake Wandawega in Elkhorn, Wisconsin. By 1928, the place had been outfitted for the distribution of prohibited liquor along with other nefarious goings on. And by 1931 the “Prohibition Padlock” had been put in place and the hotel ceased operation.

But what really happened in the first years of the seemingly ill-fated (yet still standing) Wandawega Hotel may surprise you.

3

We’re talking multiple exits, trapdoors and hidden hatches to conceal stockpiles. After a Federal raid in 1931, the place is temporarily shuttered by a “Prohibition Padlock.”

The Wandawega Hotel was the first modern building to be erected on the site that Camp Wandawega now calls home. Built in a simple, vernacular cottage style, with the modest 2×4 lumber typical of construction in Wisconsin at the time, it was clad in drop siding, roofed with asphalt shingles, and outfitted with a fieldstone fireplace. Located near a main road yet still hidden by the natural growth of the wooded area, the hotel was an ideal destination getaway for the working class people of Chicago, for those in need of an escape from the proliferating urbanity or perhaps the restrictions of Prohibition, or maybe both. Upon construction’s completion, this little lakeside hotel became populated by a motley crew of Prohibition-era ne’er-do-wells. Among the vacationers were a rotating bunch of gamblers, bootleggers, and corrupt government officials.

Little is known about why this exact site on Lake Wandawega had been chosen for the hotel. It is also not known whether or not the hotel was intentionally built for illegal activities. On the surface, particularly in the early years, the Wandawega Hotel was marketed as a genuine, American summer getaway. A 1928 advertisement beckoned readers to The Wandawega Hotel with this menu of wholesome pleasures:

“Why not enjoy your vacation at a real summer resort, plenty of good fishing, a wonderful swimming beach right at our door, a real golf course near at hand, dancing every night at ‘Wandawega Paradise,’ plenty of airy rooms overlooking the lake, real Southern cooking, and, above all, twenty-five wooded acres of land to roam in, equipped with swings, benches, and the like….”

Despite the wholesome sales pitch, it’s worth noting that the advertisement left out that the hotel was constructed to incorporate a number of hidden rooms and trap doors.

Over the course of the next fourteen years, the ‘real summer resort’ would become known for more than its “good fishing” and “real Southern cooking.” As far away as Chicago, the hotel became known as a getaway for doing dark deeds. The hotel’s infamy grew to mythical status, acting as the area’s most notorious house of ill repute.

Eventually, it would come to light that many local officials saw places like the Wandawega Hotel as a necessary evil. By confining the bootlegged liquor to out-of-the-way areas, such as the edges of Lake Wandawega, they were actually doing the public a service: keeping such activities away from Main Street, U.S.A.

The hotel first encountered a dust up with authorities in October of 1931, when Federal Prohibition officers raided and padlocked the hotel, along with fifty-seven other roadhouses in Wisconsin. The hotel’s neighbors would report that the padlocks were cut off as soon as the officers left town. In the years that followed, despite the repeal of Prohibition in 1933, the Wandawega Hotel was perpetually on the radar of law enforcement, at one point garnering statewide attention for mysteriously dropped charges involving the sale of illegal beer. With the scrutiny of the activities of The Wandawega Hotel at an all-time high, in late 1942, the hotel was charged with the “illegal sale of beer” and for “operating a house of ill fame.” With mounting legal, financial, and tax troubles, the era of The Wandawega Hotel finally came to an end.

Operating for a time as a retirement community for Latvian priests and in the summer months as a camp for boys, eventually, the priests sold to Surratt and Hernandez, and the Camp was recently added to Wisconsin’s Historic Registry.

On the hotel’s top level, at one end there is a bar which looks out onto Lake Wandawega. My nights there will occasionally end with glasses raised, a toast to those who’ve caroused in the very same spot. We’ll look up to the stars and thank them for our good luck as we enjoy our Basil Hayden’s® happy in knowing it will not end with a federal raid.

—

Camp Wandawega’s Seedy Past – Elkhorn, WI

http://wandawega.com

Back to blog