Pizzeria Beddia - Philadelphia, PA
Share

I walked into Joe Beddia’s place in the Fishtown neighborhood of Philadelphia and talk radio was blaring from the speakers overhead.
Since opening in March of 2013, Pizzeria Beddia has been busy, utilizing every inch of its 300-square-foot space to craft what critics are calling the best pizza in America.
“I wanted a smaller space,” he said. “The focus for me is on making something.”
When I arrived, mushrooms were delivered, washed, and cut. Beddia does everything but run the cash register. He is the prep kitchen, the chef, and all night long he runs the oven.
With extensive experience in the beer world, having worked for a large scale brewery prior to opening his pizzeria, Beddia is supremely knowledgeable in the worlds of high quality food and drink. However, he’s quick to point out, making beer and making pizza have a distinct difference.
“Beer was about making something consistent in large scale.”
“Unlike brewing or distilling whiskey, which could take years to perfect, making pizza has a certain immediacy. You can see it, taste it, you know whether or not it’s good because it’s right there in front of you.”
“Without getting New Age-y, it’s an extension of myself. It’s the best pizza that I can make. I’ve done a ton of traveling and research.”
He’s made a point to visit most of the great pizza places in America, taking pointers from the masters who preceded him in order to make his pies.
“I would travel and learn who was making the good pizza. Then, I’d have parties at home and I’d try to figure out the good way to do it.”
You might say pizza is in his blood.
“Not to mention that I had two uncles who had pizzerias.”
After he and his lone employee have finished preparing for the night ahead, they take a break for a couple hours and return to tidy up and open. In that time, especially since earning the title of “Best Pizza in America,” a line begins to form outside the front door. I arrived at four o’clock, an hour-and-a-half before doors opened.
I was second in line. Standing in front of me, I would come to find out, was a man who’d driven his wife and four kids from Richmond, Virginia just for this pizza.
“We brought up a vintage trailer. We’re going to all the best pizza places on the East Coast.”
He went onto explain that he’d built a brick oven in his backyard, that he was toying with the idea of opening a pizza place in Virginia.
“So, you’re pizza camping?” I asked, a sly nod to Beddia’s Instagram handle (@pizzacamp).
“Guess you could say that,” he replied.
By 5:30, we were all pizza camping. A line of 19 or 20 people had formed. It was not unlike camping in that we bonded. Pizza was our campfire. We gathered together with a common goal: buying and eating the best pizza we’d ever tried. The conversation among rookies was, “which one?” While the veterans assured that they were all great.
The system is genius, if not a little confusing to first-timers. Cash only. 40 pies a night. Order early, come back when the pie is ready. For example, Beddia knows within a minute or two what time pie number 32 will be ready.
“That’ll be ready by 9:30.”
At time of open, he switched from talk radio to a mix of road-weary country and staccato jazz.
The experience was incredible: walk into this otherwise nondescript space, order one or two pies, from the nice guy behind the counter, grab a drink, and ten minutes later, the pies come out.
I ordered my favorite, sausage, which Beddia told me he makes himself, a mix of fresh seasoning and pork from the butcher shop around the corner. And, I said, “and another, dealer’s choice.”
“The white pie,” he said, pointing at the board.
“Corn on a pizza?” I thought to myself.
The man from Virginia and his family got their pizzas first. The look of elation as they enjoyed their first bites made my stomach rumble. I’d been saving up my hunger for this pizza all day.
It was now my turn. Placed atop a gleaming stainless steel pizza stand was the first pie, the sausage. The mozzarella, a mix of aged and fresh, was still bubbling. The red Jersey Fresh tomatoes peaked out around the crust. And the crust… the crust. The dough was so expertly crafted, baked to a nice golden brown, I felt guilty leaving behind the crumbs, not to mention any uneaten crust.
But the real experience came as he reached into the oven and pulled out the second pie.
Made with a simple blend of cream, corn, and a light lemon basil pesto, topped with cherry tomatoes, and drizzled with olive oil, I could not contain my enthusiasm.
With my first bite, I was exclaiming aloud. I had been exported to a sweet, salty palace. A combination of cheese and salt and the sweet corn and then, with my second bite, I found out why this guy’s pizza rules that aforementioned palace. The cherry tomatoes were still juicy, this sweet, tart burst of flavor found its way to my tongue, and any sense of fullness I had from finishing most of the sixteen inches of the sausage pie went away. I needed to experience more of this delightful pizza.
Needless to say, I wasn’t able to finish the whole thing, but I took some back to my hotel room. It was there, a few hours later, I tried the leftovers with a splash of Basil Hayden’s®. The soft sweet corn of the bourbon and the sweet creamy corn of the pizza were an excellent complement, the perfect ending to the perfect day.










